Self-Doubt Among Teachers…Why We “Feel” Bad

This post explores the phenomena of self-doubt among teachers by asking two questions: Why is it so prevalent? Why do we feel bad?

Tonight, I was reading a blog post featured in The Washington Post by Ellie Herman. The title, Why So Many Teachers Feel Bad so Much of the Time, caught my eye. It explores the phenomena of self-doubt among teachers. Why is it so prevalent? Why do we feel bad?

I clicked on it from twitter because I was curious. As a teacher who loves my job but often feels bad, I was intrigued. Was it about all the germs lurking in public schools? Old, moldy buildings? Sleepless nights planning lessons and grading essays?
 
 No, it was about something much more abstract, but just as pervasive–self doubt.
 

Why Self-Doubt is Prevalent Among Teachers

It’s that fog that hangs over your mind at 2 AM as you can’t sleep because you feel like there must be something you forgot…that twinge that lurches through your stomach at 1 PM as an administrator ticks through a checklist at the back of your rowdy, over-crowded classroom…that jolt that electrifies your pulse at 10 AM as you listen to yet another pundit lay out yet another way to hold teachers accountable.

All of this creates self-doubt in teachers. We’re constantly told how important our job is–and how inadequate we are at doing it.

Why We Feel Bad and How to Make It Better

 

The expectations on us are high, and we’re under the microscope. We’re entrusted with our students’ learning, but we are not entrusted with creating the policy that impacts that learning. Instead, we’re viewed as incompetent at best, political fodder at worst.

It’s no wonder that doubt pervades a teacher’s professional life.

Teachers are never just teachers. We’re actors, counselors, secretaries, social workers, managers, sales people….The list goes on. How can anyone be an expert in each area?

The truth is, we can’t. We all have our strengths and weaknesses, which is why teachers’ collaborating with other teachers to create policy for the area in which we’ve been trained–many of us with several degrees and years of experience–is the only answer for actual improvements in education.

This will restore the public faith in teaching as a profession–and our faith in ourselves as professionals.

Sorry to wax political, but as we are undergoing the third major overhaul of teacher evaluations in my 12 year career, and I’m feeling “bad” about it, it seemed relevant.

Of course, as any teacher who’s been at it long enough understands, at the end of the day, we can go into our classrooms, shut out the noise, and teach. And underneath the cacophony, that’s our primary business.

What makes you feel “bad” about teaching? What is the solution? Leave a comment below to let me know.

Email
Facebook
Pinterest
Twitter

You might also like...

Colorful cut paper shapes including a pink circle, purple octagon, and green rectangle connected by yellow arrows on a teal background, representing graphic organizers for high school students and the digital graphic organizers vs paper debate for note catching strategies in the classroom.

Graphic Organizers for High School Students: Should I Use Tech for This?

You’ve heard of note-taking. Note-catching is something a little different. And that distinction is at the heart of this post. We’re looking at graphic organizers for high school students, and as part of the Should I Use Tech for This? summer series, we’re asking whether digital graphic organizers or paper serve high school students better, and the answer circles back to the same research that guided our note-taking post way back at the start of the series. We’re also covering the folded paper technique, standard annotation graphic organizers, and the one digital tool, NotebookLM, that does something for note-catching strategies that paper simply cannot replicate.

Read More »
A high school student giving a technology-enhanced presentation to classmates, illustrating creative student presentation ideas for high school and transformative technology use in the classroom.

Student Presentation Ideas for High School: When Technology Genuinely Transforms the Work

The best student presentations I’ve seen in my classroom came from a Theory of Knowledge class that turned their exhibitions into Saturday Night Live-style comedy sketches. They couldn’t have done it without technology. And they couldn’t have done it with AI alone either. In this post, part of the Should I Use Tech for This? summer series, I’m sharing what transformative student presentation ideas for high school look like, why creative student presentations go so far beyond the standard slideshow, and the one condition that makes technology work for this task rather than against it.

Read More »
Image of a magnifying glass over a dictionary for the post "Should I Use Tech for Vocabulary Practice Strategies?"

Should I Use Tech for Vocabulary Practice Strategies? What I Learned the Hard Way

I once built an elaborate digital vocabulary practice system, complete with drag-and-drop checkboxes and instructional videos, and I was so proud of it that I started selling it. It was a complete waste of everyone’s time. In this post, part of the Should I Use Tech for This? summer series, I’m sharing what that failure taught me about vocabulary practice strategies, why digital vocabulary tools for teachers shine at the surface level and fall flat at the deep and transfer levels, and how Quizlet, Quiz-Quiz-Trade, and a stack of laminated task cards all earned a permanent place in my vocabulary instruction for high school students.

Read More »

 


Welcome! Stay a while and browse classroom-tested tips, strategies, and resources that will take your teaching to the next level!

Learn More

Want Access To The Free Resource library?

Get access to 20+ classroom-tested resources!