The When Will We Ever Use This? Teaching Question: How to Balance Expectation and Reality

Podcast episode about how to respond to the “when will we ever use this” teaching question and strategies for handling student pushback in the classroom

Have you heard “when will we ever use this?” when you’re teaching and you know it’s just not about curiosity? Sometimes it’s genuine, but sometimes it’s a stall tactic dressed up as philosophy. In this episode, I’m sharing a real classroom moment that changed how I respond to student pushback for good, plus practical classroom management strategies for handling off-task students without losing instructional time or getting pulled into a debate you didn’t plan for.

You know the question. You’ve heard it a hundred times, and you’ll probably hear it again before the week’s out.

“When will we ever use this in real life?”

Here’s what nobody talks about: that question doesn’t always mean what it sounds like. Sometimes it’s genuine curiosity. Sometimes it’s a student looking for a foothold in material that feels disconnected from their life. And sometimes (if we’re being honest) it’s a very well-practiced stall tactic.

Understanding the distinction between genuine curiosity and a stall tactic is essential for effective classroom management.

You know the difference. You’ve always known.

The When Will We Ever Use This? Teaching Question

For a long time, the message to teachers has been: if students don’t understand why they’re doing something, it won’t be meaningful to them. And I believe that–to a point.

When a student’s genuinely wrestling with relevance, that conversation’s worth having.

But that message has quietly become something else: if you can’t justify every instructional choice to every student on demand, maybe you shouldn’t be making that choice. And that’s an unfair amount of pressure to put on classroom teachers.

How to Respond to Student Pushback

Knowing how to respond to student pushback starts with trusting your read of the room. I believe that’s one of the most important classroom management strategies high school (and middle school) teachers can hear.

When the question is real, engage. When it’s a game, you’re allowed to handle it differently–with humor, with honesty, and without a lengthy explanation you don’t owe anyone in that moment.

In this week’s episode, I share a story from my days as an English teacher that still makes me chuckle a little, and that changed how I handle off-task students for good. The exchange lasted about ten seconds, and I never got that particular pushback from that class again.

What This Is Really About

Some things students learn because the state says so. Because the county says so. Because it’s in the standards. That’s not a failure of pedagogy. That’s reality.

Part of what we’re teaching kids, whether we name it or not, is how to show up and do the work even when every why hasn’t been explained to their satisfaction.

This episode’s about giving teachers permission to trust that. Especially right now, with four weeks left and everyone running on fumes.

Key Takeaway: You don’t have to justify every instructional choice on demand. Knowing how to respond to student pushback with confidence is one of the most practical classroom management strategies a teacher can have.

Key Moments:

00:00 – Introduction: the when will we ever use this teaching question — and why Leah had to get outside during end-of-course testing week

Trust your instincts to discern genuine questions from stall tactics.

2:01 – Welcome back to If Teachers Ruled the World: the question every teacher dreads, especially when everyone’s running on fumes

3:19 – Meaningful learning is a worthy goal, but classroom management strategies for high school include knowing when a question is genuine curiosity vs. a stall tactic

6:37 – How to respond to student pushback without shame, over-justification, or pressure. Teachers don’t owe an explanation on demand.

6:37 – How to respond to student pushback without shame, over-justification, or pressure — and why teachers don’t owe an explanation on demand

8:01 – How to handle off-task students: trust your read, redirect with humor, and model the real-world skill of doing the work when the “why” isn’t spelled out

9:41 – Closing thoughts: four weeks left, and a reminder that teaching is a gift worth protecting

This episode is about how we can navigate the question of “when will we ever use this teaching” effectively.

Resources and Links

Students Are Asking: “Why Are We Learning This?”— And That’s a Good Thing – Junior Achievement USA (why it’s a good question…most of the time)

The Flashcard Sort: A Smart End-of-Year Review Strategy That Actually Works – If Teachers Ruled the World Podcast

Prefer Reading? I’ve Got You…

Show Transcript
00:00 This week, I’m walking and talking because it’s gorgeous outside and hoping that the sound is not too terrible. But I’ve been inside all day and it is end-of-course testing week. And so that means no planning. That means being in a room for a very long time with a whole bunch of students who are antsy and don’t want to be there. So I had to get out. I’m talking to you today about a strategy, and it’s a simple one. It’s a way to respond to students when they push back on you and ask why they have to learn something. And I’m not talking about when they say why they have to learn something and they’re genuinely curious. No, I’m talking about when they’re doing it to waste time.
2:01 Hey teachers, and welcome back to If Teachers Ruled the World. I’m Leah Cleary and we are in the home stretch. Four weeks left of school. We are so close. I can’t wait for summer. As a matter of fact, I am not recording this in my office. I am recording this episode on a walk because it is such a beautiful day. Seventy seven degrees. Gorgeous. Hopefully the sound won’t be too bad on this. So last week we talked about flash card sorting as an end of year review strategy and pinning it to your state standards or your AP course and exam description. I really hope some of you got a chance to try that. This week I want to talk about something that’s been on my mind a lot lately, something that comes up all the time, especially this time of year. When everyone, students and us are running on fumes. I want to talk about the question, I think you might know the one. When are we ever going to use this in real life? Now, before you think I’m about to tell you to always have the perfect answer ready, I’m not. Actually, I’m going to tell you the opposite. Stay with me.
3:19 Here’s the thing. There’s been a real push in education, and it’s not a bad push—it’s actually a good thing—toward making learning meaningful. Learning should be meaningful. Students should know why they’re learning things. When a kid in my AP world history class asked how something that happened three hundred years ago connects to what’s going on in the news today, I want to stop everything and have that conversation. Those moments are why we teach. Those questions are exactly what we’re hoping to spark in our classrooms. But my friends and I think you know this that’s not always what’s happening when a kid raises their hand and asks why we have to learn something. Sometimes. And I think we all know this. It’s a game. And teachers, we all know the difference. There’s the student who’s genuinely wrestling with the material, trying to find a foothold, trying to understand where all of this fits into their lives. And then there’s the kid who’s clocked that we’ve got twelve minutes left in class and has decided that a philosophical debate about the relevance of the curriculum is an excellent way to run out the clock. And we know when they’re doing that. We always know.
4:39 I want to tell you a story from my days as an English teacher. Our school had a required daily grammar practice. You’d work with the same sentence all week, and on Fridays you’d diagram it. Now, I know diagramming sentences can be kind of controversial. I mean, why would we do that? And there are very smart people who will tell you that teaching writing in context is far more effective. And they’re not wrong. But I also think diagramming has real value for certain learners, visual learners, kids who need to see the skeleton of a sentence to understand how language actually works. It was a tool, not the destination. So we did it every Friday and one Friday, a kid, a kid I genuinely adored. Loved this kid. Smart. Funny. He shot his hand up before we even got started. Why are we diagramming sentences, he asked. When are we ever going to use this in our lives? Now, I could have launched into a whole explanation of why we were doing it. The metacognitive benefits of understanding grammatical structure, the way it supports reading comprehension. The fact that if he never diagrammed another sentence after high school, the underlying skill of breaking down complex language would serve him forever. I knew all of that. I did believe all of that. But I also knew this kid and I knew exactly what he was doing. So I just looked at him and said, this is your life right now, isn’t it? He said, yes. I said, then you use it every Friday. The class laughed. He laughed. We picked up our pencils and got back to work. And I never got that particular pushback about diagramming sentences again.
6:37 Here’s what I want you to hear in that story, because I think it matters. I didn’t dismiss this kid. I didn’t shame him. But I also didn’t perform a justification I didn’t owe him in that moment. I trusted my read on the situation and I responded with humor and yes, honesty. And we moved on. And I think a lot of teachers have been told explicitly or implicitly that if you can’t justify every instructional choice to your students on demand, then maybe you shouldn’t be making that choice. That if a kid questions it and you don’t have a beautiful, meaningful answer, you’ve somehow failed them. That’s an enormous amount of pressure because we teach a lot of things, and I want to push back on that today because here’s the reality. Some things students learn, they learn because the state says so. Some things they learn because the county says so. Because the school says so. Because it’s on the AP exam. Because it’s in the standards. And is that always ideal? No, it’s absolutely not always ideal. Is everything and every curriculum perfectly designed and endlessly meaningful? I think we all know the answer to that question. But that, my friends, is also, well, it’s also just how life works sometimes.
8:01 I have things I have to do at work that I don’t fully understand the purpose of—meetings I sit in, forms I fill out, requirements I meet. And if I had been conditioned from the time I was fourteen to believe that I didn’t have to do anything I couldn’t get a thorough explanation for why I was doing first, I would never get anything done, and neither would my students. Part of what we’re actually teaching kids, whether we ever name it or not, is how to function in a world where not everything is going to be explained to their satisfaction, where sometimes you just have to put on your big kid pants and get it done. So here’s my practical takeaway for you this week, especially as you’re grinding toward the end of the year. Trust yourself to know the difference between a genuine question and a stall tactic. You do know. You, my friend, have always known and you will always know. When it’s genuine curiosity. Stop. Engage. Let it breathe. Those are the moments that make teaching great. When it’s a game, you are allowed to name it. Redirect it, or simply move forward without a full explanation. A little humor helps. This is your life right now. You don’t have to justify every instructional decision to every student, every time they push back. That’s not dismissing their agency. That’s modeling something they actually need. How to show up and do the work even when the why isn’t perfectly clear.
9:41 All right, teachers, four weeks. We’ve got this. Thank you so much for being here, for everything that you do, and for caring enough about your students to think about these things at all. If this episode resonated with you, share it with a colleague who needs to hear it. You can find me at leahcleary.com or wherever you get your podcasts. And as always, teaching is a gift. You take care of the giver. I’ll see you next time.

Listen on:

SPOTIFY
APPLE
Other Apps

Browse By Topic

Everything they forgot to mention on day one.

Teacher Wellness Teaching Strategies Teacher Advocacy Teacher Voice Be on the Podcast!